Game of Drones

The Debate Over Private Drone Use

From apps such as Yelp that help us find the best Thai restaurants within a five-block radius to sites like Google Maps that aid us in determining the fastest route to a job interview, we use satellite images daily. The convenience and efficiency of these apps and programs outweigh privacy concerns, but what about the idea of governmental and personal surveillance through the use of unregulated video shadowing?
Imagine the prospect of countless drones flying through the open sky, able to take HD video, even capable of tracking people based on the colors they wear. This seemingly futuristic dystopian vision is sparking debate across the American public: should private drone use be legal, and if so, what regulations should be present?

Personal drones – or unmanned aerial vehicles (AAVs) – are available anywhere from Amazon.com to local malls. Anyone can purchase an AAV, and the more basic models average around $300. The Parrot AR.Drone 2.0, available on Amazon, can be controlled by iPhone, iPad, and Android devices. A personal drone can be an innocently fun Christmas gift for kids, but can also be a potentially dangerous tool for stalkers and criminals. Videos collected by AAVs can be easily uploaded onto smartphones and computers, but there is no legal regulation regarding the content of the videos. Operators of personal drones may unintentionally record criminal behavior or infringe on strangers’ privacy. Of course, this raises some questions: what are the guidelines for personal privacy and is accidental invasion of privacy an enforceable offense?

Overhead territory is considered public space, so some make the argument that the physical presence of personal drones in the air is an activity that is harmless and provides no cause for legal redress. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has enforced some boundaries for private drones. AAVs, which follow the same jurisdiction as model planes, must not fly above 400 feet, must be visible from the ground, and must steer clear of airports. Even with these restrictions, the FAA does not address the privacy concerns of the public sector. For the most part, the regulations set forth by the FAA are set to ensure air safety for other aircraft, but the FAA does forbid commercial use of private drones as it is illegal for businesses to use video and photo captured by AAVs for their own benefit. However, there is no legal penalty for personal drone hobbyist use and enforcement in this sector is not within the power of the FAA.

Discussions over law enforcement of private drone use currently reside at the state level and many states are taking measures to create private drone laws. In Texas, Republican Representative Lance Gooden is pushing legislation that would effectively prohibit personal, state, and federal drone use. The bill would include a couple of exceptions, including the allowance of drones within a twenty-five mile radius of the Rio Grande for illegal immigrant and drug intervention purposes. Gooden’s hope is that this legislation will avert drones from the apprehension of “indiscriminate surveillance.” Gooden’s proposed bill exposes the problematic contentiousness surrounding drone law enforcement. Debates over federal versus state legislation, the depth of privacy concerns, the interest of personal and public safety, and the inhibition of the drone market all intersect to present greatly divided and convoluted motivations for law enforcement.

The police sector presents a sharply split dispute regarding the pros and cons of drone use. Police drone use may be useful in searching for missing persons, surveying hostage situations, and tracking suspected criminals. While the use of drones by the police has its benefits, it also raises privacy concerns, especially with respect to the Fourth Amendment. In Charlottesville, Virginia, for example, any evidence obtained by drones cannot be used in court. The city permits the police use of drones only for efforts such as search and rescue. Charlottesville presents an instance of municipal drone enforcement and the results of its legislation may provide precedence for statewide or federal law regarding drones. In Seattle, by comparison, Mayor Michael McGinn banned the use of private drones by the Seattle Police Department after public protest.

The cases in Charlottesville and Seattle illustrate public concern over unwarranted surveillance, and uncover controversies over the legislative level – municipal, state, or federal – of drone law enforcement. The debates expose not only the controversial purposes and motivations for AAV use, but also consider restrictions over who is able to use drones. Many Americans have raised concerns about neighbors or strangers using drones to spy or peep and about public agencies utilizing drones to conduct surveillance. The Association for Unmanned Vehicle Systems International (AUVSI) contests these concerns in respect to the Virginia Legislation. The AUVSI argues that public agency drone prohibition would obstruct public safety, and impede Virginia’s potential economic growth as more jobs become available within the drone and public surveillance markets.

Debate over public and private drone use presents an especially tricky predicament over the relationship between technology and legal regulation. The drone debate will continue to raise concerns in legislation, especially in subtle discrepancies between personal and public use. This controversy exposes pressing issues for present and future legal debate: can the law keep up with technology, and how does technology compromise private and public interests?

For now, it is best to choose not to embrace the paranoia – I am not worried about constantly looking overhead to see if I am being followed by a flying camera. The real concern lies in the future legislative compromise between private and public drone interests, and what this decision will illustrate about potentially increased government regulation.

 

Tucker Westbrook is a FCRH 2015 Political Science major and he may be contacted at twestbrook@fordham.edu.

525 thoughts on “Game of Drones”

  1. Pingback: yasaka scissors
  2. Pingback: publicité
  3. Pingback: barbering scissors
  4. Pingback: pocket pussy
  5. Pingback: net market
  6. Pingback: buy CBD oil
  7. Pingback: THC Vape Oil
  8. Pingback: black dildo
  9. Pingback: Recommended
  10. Pingback: nill
  11. Pingback: pc app
  12. Pingback: app for laptop
  13. Pingback: CBD gummies
  14. Pingback: Exotic carts
  15. Pingback: juul pods mint
  16. Pingback: cbd products
  17. Pingback: buy cbd
  18. Pingback: buy CBD
  19. Pingback: CBD for sale
  20. Pingback: best CBD oil
  21. Pingback: best CBD oil
  22. Pingback: best CBD oil
  23. Pingback: CBD oil for sale
  24. Pingback: buy CBD oil
  25. Pingback: CBD oil
  26. Pingback: CBD oil
  27. Pingback: corporate office
  28. Pingback: CBD
  29. Pingback: CBD
  30. Pingback: CBD
  31. Pingback: CBD
  32. Pingback: CBD
  33. Pingback: CBD
  34. Pingback: CBD
  35. Pingback: CBD
  36. Pingback: CBD
  37. Pingback: best penis pump
  38. Pingback: Buy weed online
  39. Pingback: Buy weed online
  40. Pingback: Dank vapes
  41. Pingback: safestore auto
  42. Pingback: Dank carts
  43. Pingback: THC vape oil
  44. Pingback: Pets store
  45. Pingback: vibrating dildo
  46. Pingback: coinchomp
  47. Pingback: Coinpunk
  48. Pingback: best CBD oil
  49. Pingback: CBD OIL WITH THC
  50. Pingback: CBD gummies
  51. Pingback: sex
  52. Pingback: sex lives
  53. Pingback: dax history
  54. Pingback: masturbation tips
  55. Pingback: Claypool Indiana
  56. Pingback: thrusting
  57. Pingback: Questions Nigeria
  58. Pingback: Koinonia Messages
  59. Pingback: MILF
  60. Pingback: domain authority
  61. Pingback: royal cbd
  62. Pingback: walgreens cbd oil
  63. Pingback: cbd lube
  64. Pingback: CBD oil near me
  65. Pingback: travel
  66. Pingback: free download
  67. Pingback: CBD products
  68. Pingback: webehigh
  69. Pingback: best apps
  70. Pingback: nipple toys
  71. Pingback: CBD oil
  72. Pingback: vibro panties
  73. Pingback: excursions
  74. Pingback: CBD near me
  75. Pingback: here
  76. Pingback: CBD 500mg
  77. Pingback: vape shop in uk
  78. Pingback: tulpentour holland
  79. Pingback: protrusion splint
  80. Pingback: Logo design
  81. Pingback: Cannabis Oil
  82. Pingback: hasta karyolası
  83. Pingback: pleasure beads
  84. Pingback: what is cbg oil
  85. Pingback: situs bandar poker
  86. Pingback: Exotic Carts
  87. Pingback: pornographie
  88. Pingback: Tramadol for sale
  89. Pingback: ushanka
  90. Pingback: rabbit thumper
  91. Pingback: mcq
  92. Pingback: Free Robux
  93. Pingback: CBD oils in the UK
  94. Pingback: Toronto Web Design
  95. Pingback: india visa
  96. Pingback: best smm panel
  97. Pingback: smoke shop near me
  98. Pingback: Tile installation
  99. Pingback: fda registratie
  100. Pingback: tm menards
  101. Pingback: cbd
  102. Pingback: reshp xxx
  103. Pingback: Pound of Weed
  104. Pingback: Benefits of Vaping
  105. Pingback: source
  106. Pingback: what is cbd
  107. Pingback: viagra
  108. Pingback: sex swing
  109. Pingback: Agen Poker Online
  110. Pingback: Dank Carts
  111. Pingback: vibrator
  112. Pingback: E liquid
  113. Pingback: cannabidiol
  114. Pingback: xlxx moms
  115. Pingback: cheap Viagra
  116. Pingback: Free Ads UK
  117. Pingback: pheromone spray
  118. Pingback: "cialis"
  119. Pingback: free Porn
  120. Pingback: 8 inch dong
  121. Pingback: THE CAMERA GUYS
  122. Pingback: laptop app
  123. Pingback: adult sex toys
  124. Pingback: Anambra Blogger
  125. Pingback: University
  126. Pingback: best cbd gummies
  127. Pingback: debt management
  128. Pingback: outlook sign in
  129. Pingback: Umzugsservice
  130. Pingback: enamel cookware
  131. Pingback: d33217ck
  132. Pingback: best cbd capsules
  133. Pingback: strapless pegging
  134. Pingback: dank vapes
  135. Pingback: ketamine
  136. Pingback: Frsky rc shopping
  137. Pingback: how to fuck
  138. Pingback: sexy girl lingerie
  139. Pingback: anal sex gel
  140. Pingback: Tantric Satin
  141. Pingback: SEX ONLINE
  142. Pingback: pocket stroker
  143. Pingback: vedo vibrator
  144. Pingback: anal butt plug
  145. Pingback: Google
  146. Pingback: FCMB
  147. Pingback: ssexy
  148. Pingback: suction cup dong
  149. Pingback: Google
  150. Pingback: Melanie Bowen
  151. Pingback: timberland
  152. Pingback: balenciaga
  153. Pingback: nike foamposite
  154. Pingback: yeezy boost
  155. Pingback: buy generic cialis
  156. Pingback: cheap jordans
  157. Pingback: supreme hoodie
  158. Pingback: off white
  159. Pingback: jimmy choo
  160. Pingback: polo ralph lauren
  161. Pingback: supreme new york
  162. Pingback: yeezy boost 350 v2
  163. Pingback: nike air max 90
  164. Pingback: natural cialis
  165. Pingback: viagra pill
  166. Pingback: viagra in action
  167. Pingback: cialis vs levitra
  168. Pingback: viagra cost
  169. Pingback: viagra alternative
  170. Pingback: real viagra
  171. Pingback: online viagra
  172. Pingback: cost of viagra
  173. Pingback: canadian viagra
  174. Pingback: sildenafil dosage
  175. Pingback: cialis prices 5mg
  176. Pingback: cialis prices 10mg
  177. Pingback: cialis prices 20mg
  178. Pingback: viagra sex
  179. Pingback: viagra for sale
  180. Pingback: viagra for women
  181. Pingback: sophia viagra
  182. Pingback: dutch women viagra
  183. Pingback: generic levitra
  184. Pingback: discount cialis
  185. Pingback: cialis on line
  186. Pingback: cialis black
  187. Pingback: cost of cialis
  188. Pingback: cialis medication
  189. Pingback: cialis and alcohol
  190. Pingback: otc cialis
  191. Pingback: online cialis
  192. Pingback: cialis wikipedia
  193. Pingback: cialis walmart
  194. Pingback: cialis from canada
  195. Pingback: cialis 5mg coupon
  196. Pingback: cialis 5mg
  197. Pingback: cialis soft
  198. Pingback: cialis for women
  199. Pingback: cialis for sale
  200. Pingback: liquid cialis
  201. Pingback: cialis saving card
  202. Pingback: cialis samples
  203. Pingback: generic for cialis
  204. Pingback: cialis reviews
  205. Pingback: cialis daily
  206. Pingback: cialis price
  207. Pingback: canadian cialis
  208. Pingback: cialis copay card
  209. Pingback: free cialis coupon
  210. Pingback: 5mg cialis
  211. Pingback: free cialis
  212. Pingback: what is levitra
  213. Pingback: vardenafil generic
  214. Pingback: levitra vs cialis
  215. Pingback: levitra recviews
  216. Pingback: levitra online
  217. Pingback: what is levaquin
  218. Pingback: augmentin uses
  219. Pingback: levaquin uses
  220. Pingback: augmentin for uti
  221. Pingback: levitra cost
  222. Pingback: sildenafil coupons
  223. Pingback: augmentin dose
  224. Pingback: levaquin for uti
  225. Pingback: augmentin dosage
  226. Pingback: buy levitra online
  227. Pingback: cheap levitra
  228. Pingback: levaquin 750 mg
  229. Pingback: augmentin 875 mg
  230. Pingback: buy levitra
  231. Pingback: levaquin 500 mg
  232. Pingback: augmentin 875
  233. Pingback: levaquin
  234. Pingback: augmentin
  235. Pingback: duloxetine 60 mg
  236. Pingback: duloxetine hcl
  237. Pingback: vardenafil 20mg
  238. Pingback: duloxetine 20 mg
  239. Pingback: vardenafil 20 mg
  240. Pingback: vardenafil
  241. Pingback: levitra vs viagra
  242. Pingback: cymbalta reviews
  243. Pingback: levitra dosage
  244. Pingback: levitra coupon
  245. Pingback: cymbalta generic
  246. Pingback: levitra 20 mg
  247. Pingback: cymbalta for pain
  248. Pingback: atorvastatin 10mg
  249. Pingback: cymbalta dosage
  250. Pingback: atorvastatin 10 mg
  251. Pingback: levitra generic
  252. Pingback: cymbalta
  253. Pingback: atorvastatin
  254. Pingback: cialis free trial
  255. Pingback: cialis cooupons
  256. Pingback: cialis coupons
  257. Pingback: cialis cost
  258. Pingback: wiki escitalopram
  259. Pingback: tadalafila
  260. Pingback: cialis generika
  261. Pingback: cialis generico
  262. Pingback: cialis 20 mg
  263. Pingback: cialis 5 mg
  264. Pingback: viagra for men
  265. Pingback: female viagra
  266. Pingback: viagra on line
  267. Pingback: natural viagra
  268. Pingback: bactrim antibiotic
  269. Pingback: cefdinir 300 mg
  270. Pingback: levitra
  271. Pingback: fluconazole 150 mg
  272. Pingback: cephalexin 500mg
  273. Pingback: biaxin antibiotic
  274. Pingback: prozac generic
  275. Pingback: fluoxetine 20 mg
  276. Pingback: sildenafil 100 mg
  277. Pingback: cialis tadalafil
  278. Pingback: sildenafil tablets
  279. Pingback: buy cialis online
  280. Pingback: sildenafil generic
  281. Pingback: cialis tablets
  282. Pingback: sildenafil 50 mg
  283. Pingback: sildenafil
  284. Pingback: lazo real madrid
  285. Pingback: buy sildenafil
  286. Pingback: prednisone 20 mg
  287. Pingback: buy cordarone
  288. Pingback: buy cialis
  289. Pingback: chloromycetin
  290. Pingback: buy biaxin online
  291. Pingback: buy chloromycetin
  292. Pingback: buy ceftin
  293. Pingback: buy biaxin
  294. Pingback: sildenafil 100
  295. Pingback: sildenafil 100mg
  296. Pingback: sildenafil 20 mg
  297. Pingback: viagra tablet
  298. Pingback: buy viagra online
  299. Pingback: cheap viagra
  300. Pingback: viagra coupons
  301. Pingback: viagra generic
  302. Pingback: viagra prices
  303. Pingback: viagra online
  304. Pingback: buy viagra
  305. Pingback: viagra 100mg
  306. Pingback: viagra pills
  307. Pingback: sildenafil citrate
  308. Pingback: viagra
  309. Pingback: cialis canada
  310. Pingback: cheap cialis
  311. Pingback: cialis pills
  312. Pingback: tadalafil generic
  313. Pingback: tadalafil 20 mg
  314. Pingback: cialis vs viagra
  315. Pingback: cialis coupon
  316. Pingback: cialis generic
  317. Pingback: cialis
  318. Pingback: viagra natural
  319. Pingback: viagra connect
  320. Pingback: generic viagra
  321. Pingback: viagra vs cialis
  322. Pingback: cialis prices
  323. Pingback: cialis dosage
  324. Pingback: tadalafil
  325. Pingback: cialis 20mg
  326. Pingback: fotbollströjor
  327. Pingback: viagra tablets
  328. Pingback: tadalafil 20mg
  329. Pingback: tadalafil 5mg
  330. Pingback: cialis online
  331. Pingback: generic cialis
  332. Pingback: maglie calcio

Leave a Reply