The Humanitarian Military

Why we need new approaches to civil-military cooperation in humanitarian affairs

For as long as there have been wars, there has been the need to clean up after them. One of the most important tasks in post-conflict reconstruction has been to return societies to a state of normalcy. Traditionally, militaries and humanitarian organizations undertake this role separately, each with their own set of mandates. Beginning in the 1990s, however, their mandates began to intersect, with increasing intensity in the second half of the decade. The international community’s response thus far has been to clearly demarcate militaries and humanitarian actors, with strict guidelines prescribing their cooperation. The bad news? This approach is outdated, and needs fixing – urgently.

Human security was a concept first articulated in the United Nations Development Program’s 1994 Human Development Report. As a principle, it has formed the basis for military action in humanitarian crises, encompassing concerns and challenges above merely defending state sovereignty. Human security became a ubiquitous international norm with the conclusion of the Cold War. Peacekeeping has evolved from traditional missions to what the United Nations terms “complex multidimensional enterprises.” Militaries play a crucial stabilizing role in post-conflict situations, from peacekeeping operations in Sudan, to humanitarian assistance in the Horn of Africa. More national armed forces are participating in humanitarian and disaster relief operations and peace-support operations of increasing scope, complexity, and frequency.

What is the role for militaries in humanitarian crises?
Disciples of the famed Prussian General Carl von Clausewitz argue that military action should be an extension of strategy. Military forces therefore should engage in humanitarian efforts as part of a “deliberate strategy designed to encroach upon traditional humanitarian space,” according to the Humanitarian Practice Network, a UK-based humanitarian think-tank. Advocating for greater military involvement, defense officials point toward practical needs. They argue the need to respond to the perceived inadequacies in ground operations. External military forces must often maintain law and order, or provide military and political support to local governance structures that had been weakened by conflicts. Military support also provides assistance in delivering relief and protecting supplies, convoys, and staff.

Opponents blame military involvement for compromising the fundamental tenets of humanitarian aid, namely: impartiality, neutrality, and independence. What these principles mean is that aid must be disbursed solely on the basis of need, that aid organizations cannot take sides in a conflict, and that aid should only go towards humanitarian needs. These have a practical purpose. By adhering to these principles humanitarian organizations can gain access to people in need. Apolitical agencies such as the International Committee of the Red Cross, for instance, enjoy far better access to target populations for this very reason. When the founders of Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF), or Doctors Without Borders, left the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) to establish their organization in 1971, they did so to emphasize the importance of bearing witness to endangered populations, an inherently political mission. Today, the ICRC is able to operate in many more locations than MSF.

Militaries are, by their very nature, partial. They weigh the costs and benefits of allying with certain groups over others, a calculation informed by geography and political, cultural and social affiliations. Intervention aligns militaries with humanitarian agencies, putting them at risk of local hostility. Dadaab, Kenya is home to a refugee camp housing the largest number of Somali refugees. After two of its aid workers were kidnapped from the Dadaab refugee camp in February 2012, MSF was quick to distance itself from the Kenyan government. Military involvement may often undermine humanitarian efforts.

Other skeptics among the humanitarian NGO community argue that military interventions are neither cost-effective nor practical. They say that military aid is unsustainable, merely focused on the short term, and unable to adapt to local conditions. Militaries are most often involved in humanitarian work in the aftermath of conflicts, an almost natural extension of their roles. In recent years this involvement has only intensified. In 2006, the United States Department of Defense released a directive boosting military involvement in post-conflict reconstruction efforts. This directive would increase collaborations between NGOs and the military and more governmental involvement in humanitarian assistance. Groups like Oxfam and the International Rescue Committee condemned the directive, citing the danger of politicizing humanitarian aid and crippling aid organizations’ ability to carry out their work.

Still, apologists for a military-led approach argue that militaries stabilize dangerous situations. Modern conflicts are very complex creatures that require time and resources to resolve. Long after the end of formal hostilities in Afghanistan, the Pakistani army still stations 10,000 men in its northern tribal areas on UN peacekeeping missions. Still, if humanitarian aid is a messy business, then military involvement only worsens it. The issue is that, as humanitarian and military mandates intersect, we are left with a new creature. And we have not learned how to manage it yet.

The Humanitarian Military
The world faces a new form of military activity in humanitarian spaces. In the wake of the 2010 earthquake in Haiti, the United States Department of Defense dispatched military units to participate in humanitarian efforts. A day after the earthquake struck, C-130 Hercules aircraft had airdropped 6 tons of cargo, vehicles, and equipment. Within a week, the USS Bataan had brought US Marines to Haiti to begin reconstruction efforts.

But militaries should not be beholden to the same rules as humanitarian agencies, and vice versa. Take, for instance, the Oslo Guidelines. Introduced in 1994 as rules to govern military aid in humanitarian work, they were revised in 2006 as a response to the unprecedented deployment of military forces following the natural disasters in 2005. These guidelines apply to disaster relief operations. But no equivalent guidelines exist for post-conflict reconstruction.
In fact, militaries in post-conflict humanitarian work often contravene these guidelines. Militaries often prefer to take the lead, refusing to cede authority to civilians—and as a result military and humanitarian operations often intersect. Furthermore, these engagements are plagued with the lack of a clear exit strategy. The problem is, these are the day-to-day realities of military deployments. Militaries are in the business of waging war, and humanitarian aid is an entirely new dimension to their work. Worse still, military forces are intensely mission-driven, putting them fundamentally at odds with humanitarianism. To accomplish “hearts and minds” counter-insurgency campaigns, some militaries even pursue overtly humanitarian objectives. Donald Steinberg, of the International Crisis Group, noted that soldiers are insufficiently trained to handle the social complexities of humanitarian crises. Adjusting to the realities of operating in a humanitarian space will require a fundamental realignment.

One potential solution is for governments to define the nature and scope of military operations in humanitarian settings. Civil-military cooperation may not be a bad thing. In many cases, it may even be the best solution in a bad situation. The problem arises in dealing with the emergence of new creature: the humanitarian military. Without proper guidelines, militaries and humanitarian organizations will be gambling with the lives of those they were meant to save.

Brendan Foo was a senior at Fordham College at Lincoln Center and can be contacted at bfoo@fordham.edu.

Related posts

83 Thoughts to “The Humanitarian Military”

  1. Omaha car injury lawyer

    Purchase the professional automobile injury attorney currently available and ready to go now in addition gets your life back today!

  2. crossfire brass burner

    Get an amazing Montana Fire Pit currently available and now in stock and at great prices today and tommorrow only!

  3. See More

    locate professional assistance truck accident lawyer that’s available and ready to start in addition gets results today!

  4. Omaha car injury lawyer

    Purchase professional assistance Learn More currently available and ready to go now in addition gets results today!

  5. Nebraska truck accident attorney

    Purchase professional assistance personal injury lawyer that’s available and ready to start in addition gets your life back today!

  6. motorcycle attorney

    Purchase legal help motorcycle accident attorney currently available and ready to start and gets your life back today!

  7. automobile injury attorney

    Buy the professional See More currently available and ready to start in addition gets results today!

  8. truck accident attorney

    locate legal help bike accident lawyer that is available and ready to go now in addition gets you results today!

  9. car injury attorney

    locate professional assistance car injury lawyer that is available and ready to start and gets you results today!

  10. accident lawyer

    Purchase the professional motorcycle lawyer that’s available and ready to start and gets you results today!

  11. View More

    Purchase professional assistance motorcycle accident claims that is available and ready to start in addition gets you results today!

  12. Omaha car injury lawyer

    Buy professional assistance motorcycle accident claims that’s available and ready to go now in addition gets results today!

  13. truck accident attorney

    locate the professional Omaha personal injury attorney that’s available and ready to go now and gets you results today!

  14. montana fire pits

    Get an amazing Warming trends fire pit that are available and in stock and at great prices today and tommorrow only!

  15. outdoor fire tables

    Get a design for a top brass fire pit burners that are available and in stock and currently available today and tommorrow only!

  16. warming trendscrossfire brass burner

    Get a design for the best montana fire pits that are available and now in stock in addition reasonably priced today and tommorrow only!

  17. warming trends dealers

    Get parts for a top Montana Firepit that’s available and in stock in addition at the best price today and tommorrow only!

  18. warming trends gas burners

    Get a design for the best natural gas fire pits for decks that is available and in stock and at the best price today and tommorrow only!

  19. Montana Firepits

    Get parts for an amazing Warming trends fire pit kit currently available and in stock in addition at the best price today and tommorrow only!

  20. School bell system

    Purchase amazing wireless pa speakers that’s available and now in stock and at the best price get it now only!

  21. Montana Firepits

    Get the best high quality fire pits that’s available and in stock and currently available today and tommorrow only!

  22. crossfire brass burner

    Get an amazing warming trendscrossfire brass burner that’s available and now in stock and at the best price today and tommorrow only!

  23. Natural gas fire pit burners

    Get the best Gas fire pit burner currently available and in stock and on sale today and tommorrow only!

  24. outdoor fire tables

    Get a design for the best Click Here that are available and in stock in addition at a great price today and tommorrow only!

  25. Montana Firepits

    Get a design for a top Montana Fire Pits that is available and now in stock and currently available today and tommorrow only!

  26. propane fire pit control valve

    Get a design for a top gas fire pit burners that are available and in stock in addition at the best price today and tommorrow only!

  27. fire pit bowls

    Get a top outdoor fire tables currently available and in stock and on sale today and tommorrow only!

  28. gas fire pit replacement logs

    Get parts for the best crossfire burner that’s available and now in stock and reasonably priced today and tommorrow only!

  29. school bell system

    Buy the top wireless pa system for schools currently available and in stock and at great prices get it now only!

  30. gas fire pit insert

    Get a top propane fire pit burner that is available and in stock in addition at great prices today and tommorrow only!

  31. Visit Now

    Get a design for an amazing Montana Firepit that is available and now in stock and at great prices today and tommorrow only!

  32. wireless pa system for schools

    locate the top school p a system that is available and now in stock and at the best price get it now only!

  33. montana fire pits

    Get a design for the best Fire pit lava rock that is available and in stock and at a great price today and tommorrow only!

  34. crossfire brass burners

    Get parts for a top gas fire pit replacement logs that are available and in stock and on sale today and tommorrow only!

  35. school pa systems

    Buy amazing school pa systems currently available and in stock in addition currently available get it now only!

  36. outdoor fire pit replacement parts

    Get an amazing Logs for gas fire pit currently available and now in stock and at the best price today and tommorrow only!

  37. replacement quartz clock movements

    Buy the best clock parts for crafts that’s available and in stock and at the best price get it now only!

  38. fire pit main control valve

    Get a design for a top Warming trends fire pit kit that are available and in stock in addition at great prices today and tommorrow only!

  39. crossfire brass burner

    Get parts for a top outdoor fire tables currently available and now in stock in addition reasonably priced today and tommorrow only!

  40. montana fire pits

    Get parts for an amazing outdoor gas fire pit kit that are available and in stock in addition at great prices today and tommorrow only!

  41. high quality fire pits

    Get parts for the best warming trendscrossfire brass burner that is available and now in stock in addition reasonably priced today and tommorrow only!

  42. Fire pit lava rock

    Get parts for an amazing ceramic logs for outdoor fire pit that’s available and in stock and at the best price today and tommorrow only!

  43. Montana Fire Pit

    Get parts for a top ceramic logs for outdoor fire pit currently available and now in stock and currently available today and tommorrow only!

  44. gas fire pit replacement logs

    Get parts for a top View More that is available and now in stock in addition currently available today and tommorrow only!

  45. gas fire pit replacement logs

    Get parts for a top propane fire pit burner that are available and in stock in addition on sale today and tommorrow only!

  46. Visit Now

    Get a design for a top outdoor fire tables that is available and in stock and at the best price today and tommorrow only!

  47. pa system for school

    Purchase the top wireless pa speakers that is available and now in stock in addition reasonably priced get it now only!

  48. School bell system

    Buy the best wireless pa system that’s available and in stock and at the best price get it now only!

  49. Warming trends fire pits

    Get a design for the best See More currently available and now in stock and reasonably priced today and tommorrow only!

  50. natural gas fire pits for decks

    Get an amazing Warming trends fire pit kit that is available and now in stock and on sale today and tommorrow only!

  51. replacement logs for gas fire pit

    Get parts for a top propane fire pit control valve that’s available and now in stock in addition reasonably priced today and tommorrow only!

  52. diy gas fire pit burner

    Get a top natural gas fire pits for decks that are available and in stock in addition at a great price today and tommorrow only!

  53. school pa system

    locate the best school bell scheduling systems that is available and in stock in addition on sale get it now only!

  54. clock movements

    locate amazing clockkits that is available and in stock and on sale get it now only!

  55. warming trendscrossfire brass burner

    Get a design for the best crossfire brass burner that’s available and now in stock and currently available today and tommorrow only!

  56. click the internet site

    locate amazing school pa system that is available and in stock and at great prices get it now only!

  57. pa speakers

    Buy amazing public announcement speakers currently available and in stock in addition at great prices get it now only!

  58. diy gas fire pit burner

    Get a design for an amazing replacement logs for gas fire pit currently available and now in stock and at great prices today and tommorrow only!

  59. propane fire pit burner

    Get the best Click Here that’s available and now in stock in addition currently available today and tommorrow only!

  60. wireless clock system

    Purchase amazing school bell systems that are available and in stock and reasonably priced get it now only!

  61. clock kits

    Purchase the top clock replacement parts currently available and in stock in addition at the best price get it now only!

  62. Warming trends fire pit

    Get a design for the best fire pit bowls that is available and in stock in addition at the best price today and tommorrow only!

  63. wireless pa system

    locate the best wireless pa speakers that is available and in stock and at the best price get it now only!

  64. wireless pa system for schools

    Buy the best school pa system that is available and in stock in addition at the best price get it now only!

  65. crossfire brass burner

    Get parts for a top crossfire brass burners that is available and now in stock in addition at great prices today and tommorrow only!

  66. montana fire pits

    Get parts for an amazing warming trendscrossfire brass burner that are available and now in stock in addition at the best price today and tommorrow only!

  67. Click On this site

    locate amazing wireless pa system that is available and in stock and on sale get it now only!

  68. clock mechanisms

    Buy the top battery operated quartz clock movements that are available and in stock and reasonably priced get it now only!

  69. click the web page

    locate amazing school public address system that’s available and in stock in addition reasonably priced get it now only!

  70. clock movement kit

    Purchase the best clock parts that is available and now in stock in addition reasonably priced get it now only!

  71. pa system for school

    Buy the best wireless public address system that’s available and now in stock in addition on sale get it now only!

  72. Clock kit suppliers

    Buy the best clock building kit that are available and now in stock in addition at the best price get it now only!

  73. clock parts for crafts

    Purchase the top where to buy quartz clock movements that’s available and now in stock and on sale get it now only!

  74. Click Link

    locate amazing school clock and bell systems that is available and in stock and at great prices get it now only!

  75. wall clock kits

    locate amazing wholesale clock movement kits that are available and now in stock and currently available get it now only!

  76. synchronized clocks

    Buy amazing school clock and bell systems that are available and now in stock and at great prices get it now only!

  77. large clock kit

    Buy the top replacement clock mechanism that is available and now in stock and currently available get it now only!

  78. wireless pa system for schools

    Buy amazing wireless pa system that’s available and now in stock in addition at great prices get it now only!

  79. where to buy quartz clock movements

    Purchase amazing clock kits that is available and in stock and on sale get it now only!

  80. Misconceptions and Facts: Lies and Truth About the Business of Modeling

    Obtaining success in the market depends heavily on the knowledge about its truths.

  81. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Informations here: fordhampoliticalreview.org/the-humanitarian-military/ […]

  82. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More: fordhampoliticalreview.org/the-humanitarian-military/ […]

  83. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More Infos here: fordhampoliticalreview.org/the-humanitarian-military/ […]

Leave a Comment