The Possibility of Democracy in Fragmented Arab Societies

Two years ago, unified opposition against the Middle East’s authoritarian regimes characterized the Arab uprisings. All the slogans shared the underlying mantra, “We want change”—change of the regime, change of the economic status quo, change of the political oppression, and change of the fearful silence.

Two years later, however, unified opposition has transformed into internal fragmentation and polarization in each country, whether they have entered a period of transition—like Tunisia, Egypt, and Libya—or not. Syria’s uprisings have spiraled into civil war. Meanwhile, in Jordan and Morocco, tensions fester below the surface as some citizens are increasingly displeased with the cosmetic changes that their respective governments implemented to quell the 2011 protests. Egypt’s transition remains in the international eye while Tunisia, where the uprisings of the Arab world began in January 2011, has faded almost wholly from global public discourse. Despite their differing face time in the media, the Egyptian and Tunisian transitions are plagued with similar sectarian polarization that, for many Westerners, seemingly denote the failure of the so-called “Arab Spring” in instituting democracy throughout the Middle East. Yet, elections, constitution writing, and continued societal debate in Egypt and Tunisia underscore an evolving reality that was virtually impossible under Mubarak and Ben Ali. However, the internal sectarian polarization in both countries threatens their respective transitions to democracy insofar as it divides the nations that, only as unified fronts, were successful in overthrowing repressive dictators.

The sectarian divide has manifested differently in the last two years, being more apparent in Egypt than in Tunisia. Moderate, liberal, and secular Egyptians criticized the Muslim Brotherhood for its reluctance to join the 2011 uprisings, its alleged politicking with the widely unpopular Security Council of Armed Forces (SCAF), and its push to hold the country’s first post-Mubarak elections before rewriting its constitution. Meanwhile, Tunisians—whose country, before the uprisings of 2011, was considered one of the more liberal in the region—were hesitant to accept Ennahda’s rising leadership. Both Egyptians and Tunisians questioned the parties’ self-proclaimed modernized form of political Islam. Through passive political participation and social programs, however, the Muslim Brotherhood and Ennahda garnered the necessary support to win elections, successfully attaining control of their respective governments.

In an attempt to maintain their newly acquired power, especially after being politically oppressed for decades, both the Muslim Brotherhood and Ennahda have confirmed—and, to some extent, exacerbated—worries that premature elections would lead to another oppressive, overreaching government. The Muslim Brotherhood has demonstrated worrisome tendencies resembling those of SCAF and Mubarak. Most notable, President Morsi assumed SCAF’s unlimited, controversial authority in June 2012 and then, late last November, decreed essentially absolute power for the president. Although he rescinded the latter decree, Morsi has thus far failed to take moderate, liberal, and secular voices into account, particularly in regards to the constitution. Similarly, the Ennahda-controlled government and constitution-writing body have exhibited more conservative tendencies than those with which they campaigned during elections. The National Constituent Assembly, which was elected in 2011 to write the constitution, failed to include safeguards protecting fundamental freedoms (namely those of expression and conscience), women’s rights, and anti-discrimination. Instead, the constitution depended more heavily on shari’a than initially expected.

The Islamist framework of both parties has added a sectarian element to the national divisions, which are inherent in times of political change and transformation. Like Mubarak’s National Democratic Party and Ben Ali’s Rally for Constitutional Democracy, the Muslim Brotherhood and Ennahda have become the dominant parties struggling to maintain power while vying against moderate, liberal, and secular opponents for political legitimacy. Therefore, neither Islamist government has made substantial strides to rectify the failing economies, address the unemployment rates, or alleviate their respective country’s poverty—all of which were among the factors that fueled the 2011 Arab uprisings. These shortcomings have rendered a perceived failure of the “Arab Spring,” with Islamist and secular parties pointing the finger at each other.

The immediate secular polarization, however, does not hamper the possibility of long-term democracy in Egypt or Tunisia. In the short-term, any form of fragmentation—sectarian, political, economic, or social in nature—will surely prolong the transition from authoritarianism to democracy. The 2011 Arab uprisings created a new space for public debate and discourse in Egypt and Tunisia, thus enabling the rise of various opinions. The very existence of this outright, apparent fragmentation signifies a shift from the Mubarak and Ben Ali regimes, under which critics of the government were jailed, tortured, and/or killed—as is still occurring in Syria, Jordan, and Bahrain. In other words, this evident societal polarization highlights an increased public discourse once impossible in the Middle East. Rather, the true danger to democracy rests in the long-term continuation of such divisions, which will occur unless Islamists and secularists alike begin to work towards the changes once called for two years ago.

 

Anna Maria Shaker is our Middle Eastern Affairs Editor and a Middle Eastern Studies major, FCRH 2013. She may be contacted at ashaker@fordham.edu.

Related posts

38 Thoughts to “The Possibility of Democracy in Fragmented Arab Societies”

  1. ubelief kids winter pants boys winter trousers toddler boy winter pants baby boy kids down jacket pants baby down feather pants in pants from mother kids

    best super deals men running shoes nike air max 95 sneakerboot sku 94399 253this summer s end triangle scarf is the perfect way to transition from summer to fall. with bold fall colored yarnbeautoday mules shoes women genuine leather round toe new fash…

  2. casaca barcelona original nike. cargando zoom

    physiocarrier jpmbb coton tablier noir poche iris contre ton coeurdsquared2 pull col roul茅 femme v锚tementsecharpe capuche noir urban classics la redouteafblr col 茅charpe ch芒le 茅charpe 脿 carreaux femme imitation 茅charpe triangle automne et

  3. 賵賰丕賱丞 丕賱乇兀賷 丕賱賮賱爻胤賷賳賷丞 卮乇賰丞 adidas 鬲胤賱賯 賰乇丞 賯丿賲 匕賰賷丞

    丕噩賲賱 賲丕乇賰丕鬲 卮賳胤 賷丿 丕賷胤丕賱賶馃憶丕噩賲賱 賲賵丿賷賱丕鬲 卮賳胤 丨乇賷賲賶 乇賵毓賴馃憸丕丨丿孬 丕卮賰丕賱賮爻鬲丕賳 丕賱丿丕賳鬲賷賱 丕賱賮禺賲 亘丕賱賱賵賳 丕賱爻賰乇賷 亘賯氐丞 毓氐乇賷丞亘丕賯丕鬲 賵 毓乇賵囟 a dsl 賲賳 賮賵丿丕賮賵賳 亘丕賱鬲賮丕氐賷賱 丕賱賰丕賲賱丞bags buy bags products online in 丕賱丕賲丕乇丕鬲 丕賱毓乇亘賷丞 丕賱賲鬲丨丿丞

  4. Jordan 11 Concord

    Appearing at the same She The People forum, Bernie Sanders was heckled by several audience members while he recalled participating in the March on Washington in 1963 and hearing Martin Luther King Jr.’s “I Have a Dream” speech.

  5. prodejn铆 boty kilimanjaro arctic calando iclmcyr 膷ern谩 zimn铆 obuv

    p谩nsk茅 boty nike nike air jordan 2 retro low b铆l茅 ko啪en茅 athletic tr茅ninkov茅 boty nike pro p谩nsk茅 v媒prodejspodn铆 pr谩dlo dim d臎tsk媒 bazar10 najlep拧铆ch zna膷iek elegantnej obuvi. od renomovan媒ch dizajn茅rov a啪 po dvestoro膷n茅 obuvn铆cke es谩 z anglicka001 spo…

  6. lanius damen strickpullover manufactum

    miniatura de perfume importado chlo茅 edt femininochloe poppy 133s 211 oculos de solveja o 1陋 flagra de beijo na boca de larissa manoela e jo茫o guilherme bol v铆deosbolsa michael kors selma navy blue lan莽amento mk r 699

  7. natural face wash anti aging facial cleanser by goodonya. organic ingredients

    babyliss 6609e le pro light hair dryer ba 6609e5 in 1 electric facial pore cleaner natural remedies directthe bellezza wet2dry flat iron on curly hair youtubeexperience ghd straight and smooth spray a lightweight

  8. React Element 87

    When asked about the past social media posts during his introductory news conference on Friday, Bosa apologized for tweeting in the summer of 2016 that Kaepernick was a “clown.”

  9. NFL Jerseys

    Traditionally, both professional and collegiate teams are invited to celebrate with the President at the White House after winning a championship. Under the Trump administration, however, this has not always been the case. Several teams, both collegiat…

  10. diesel just yo t shirt

    8100 jpy edwin 402xv edwin ex402 100 mens tight denim jeans 33 made in japanspectacular sales for diesel t shirtseastpak eastpak bagsbec bridge snake charmer bandage dress look books

  11. cheap lebron james chinadiscount lebron james china

    buy nike roshe flyknit air jordan 1 retro ultra high mens shoeair jordan 10 retro hornets gets a release date sneaker shoutsfive people have been charged in new york with trafficking in counterfeit nike air jordans that if authentic would have been wor…

  12. nike air jordan 6 retro vi maroon og aj6 6s sz 10.5 ebay

    air jordan 6 rings premier motorsports white black jordan sneakers 12 100 top quality. jordan space jam 11 sizesupreme x air jordan t shirt xl sizenike jordan jumpman boys mens lined skull cap beanie hat red fleeceair jordan xxx aj30 blanc jaune bleu c…

  13. air jordan vii olympic aj 7 og available on ebay

    air jordan 11 retro 70 10 yoplugkids hats caps sun hats zalandojordan brand air jordan 10 retro 310805 002 sneakersnstuffbeef over a ap rocky travi scott appear in photo together

  14. boohooman ribbed fisherman beanie in black products pinterest

    light blue neff beanie parchmentnleadgeebro womens beanie hat authentic winter cashmere hats rhinestones hats for female women hat knitted woolmen winter wool ivy flat hat cap with ear warmer flap solid black gray navy g70welcome skateboards talisman b…

  15. heldragt med hat xxxl

    wellcoda vegetariam phrase femme s 2xl sweat 脿 capuchebonobo jeans pull femme 茅toiles dor茅esachat chaussures sweet r femme mulegeox derbies carnaby chaussures homme derbies ventes en ligne

  16. Yeezy

    taxjupbupdl Yeezy,Thanks for this useful information, Really amazing. Thanks again. I LOve your BloG

  17. Yeezy 350

    ruoochbqk,Thanks for sharing this recipe with us!!

  18. Yeezy

    iurjxzp Yeezy Shoes,Thanks a lot for providing us with this recipe of Cranberry Brisket. I’ve been wanting to make this for a long time but I couldn’t find the right recipe. Thanks to your help here, I can now make this dish easily.

  19. Pandora Jewelry

    lvvjcrev,Thanks for ones marvelous posting! I actually enjoyed reading it, you will be a great author.I will always bookmark your blog and will tmmmcbhrvs,come back from now on. I want to encourage that you continue your great writing, have a nice afte…

  20. justin tucker signed ravens jersey ga coa at pristineauction.com

    germany home shirt world cup 2018 women football shirtsclown lives matter dont shoot the clown awareness t shirtsynthetic upper antony kj n5 morato zip detail polo shirt for men clothing blackboss smart casual children boys pique polo shirt

  21. 2017 the most popular converse chuck taylor classic all star high hi

    men麓s bracelet with crystals swarovski oliver weber beads 67022converse jack purcell maroon ready stock mens fashion footwear sneakers onconverse chuck taylor all star dainty ox w dames wit wit wit converse schoenen 3677men s converse chuck taylor all…

  22. Nike Vapormax Flyknit

    blbfyxl,If you are going for best contents like I do, just go to see this web page daily because it offers quality contents, thanks!

  23. panama jersey world cup 2018 wholesale online

    womens laptop cover bagnike air max tailwind 7 black white mens 683632 001running shoes outfit wanelo.cowomens all black leather slip on sneakers

  24. Yeezy Boost 700

    qxigye,If you are going for best contents like I do, just go to see this web page daily because it offers quality contents, thanks!

  25. Nike Outlet store

    ptpxwjxum,Definitely believe that which you said. Your favourite justification appeared to be on the net the simplest thing to remember of.

  26. Nike Outlet Online

    vwymsedsqwi,Hi there, just wanted to say, I liked this article. It was helpful. Keep on posting!

  27. Yeezy

    znxcejeuq Adidas Yeezy,Thanks for sharing this recipe with us!!

  28. Cheap Nike NBA Jerseys

    lezteuwqmdz,Definitely believe that which you said. Your favourite justification appeared to be on the net the simplest thing to remember of.

  29. Yeezy Boost 350 V2

    ztheri,Some really nice stuff on this website, I enjoy it.

  30. Nike Outlet

    zjfnzkqsin,If you want a hassle free movies downloading then you must need an app like showbox which may provide best ever user friendly interface.

  31. Yeezys

    Game Killer Apk Download Latest Version for Android (No Ad) … Guess not because Game killer full version app is not available on Play store.

  32. Air Max 270

    oglybhftsri,We have a team of experts who could get you the correct settings for Bellsouth net email login through which, you can easily configure your email account with MS Outlook.

  33. Nike Air Zoom Pegasus 35

    qxhzhi,A very good informative article. I’ve bookmarked your website and will be checking back in future!

  34. Balenciaga

    nqqwqpnp,Some really nice stuff on this website, I enjoy it.

  35. jordan 11 concord 2018

    opywxybyfar,Very informative useful, infect very precise and to the point. I’m a student a Business Education and surfing things on Google and found your website and found it very informative.

  36. Nike Pegasus 35

    owohcrhniw,If you have any struggle to download KineMaster for PC just visit this site.

  37. Adidas Yeezys

    fmpajoglijk,If you want a hassle free movies downloading then you must need an app like showbox which may provide best ever user friendly interface.

  38. Nike Air Max 270

    vkzdwi,If you want a hassle free movies downloading then you must need an app like showbox which may provide best ever user friendly interface.

Leave a Comment